AI Avatar Video: Is It Worth It?

Find out if videos with AI avatars are worth it. Explore the advantages and challenges of this emerging technology and its impact on video production.

Demonstração do produto Synthesia com avatar digital em fundo lilás, interface de usuário para criação de vídeo por IA.

With the advancement of artificial intelligence, one of the most sought-after applications today is videos with AI avatars on platforms such as Synthesia, Heygen and others. On the one hand, the costs are lower than recording with real people, but the technology still faces significant challenges.

Businesses across industries are adopting this technology to create content more efficiently. However, there are still questions about the quality and effectiveness of these videos. Is it worth investing in AI avatars? Let’s find out.

What are AI avatar videos?

AI avatar videos use artificial intelligence technology to create digital characters that can speak and move like humans. Platforms like Synthesia and HeyGen allow businesses to create videos quickly and cost-effectively, without the need for actors or studios.

How does AI avatar technology work?

Contrary to what many people think, it is not exactly a digital avatar created from scratch. Instead, the technology uses real actors, usually foreigners, who license their image to the platform.

These actors record several hours of content against a chroma key background. The technology then creates a 3D mesh of the actor’s face, allowing the system to lip-sync and add gestures and facial expressions. This process allows the avatar to appear to be speaking any text provided by the company, while maintaining a certain level of realism and dynamism.

Advantages of AI Avatars

1. Cost Reduction

Producing videos with AI avatars is significantly cheaper than shooting with actors or staff. There’s no need to rent studios, hire cameras, or pay for complex editing. Platforms like Synthesia offer affordable plans, allowing you to create multiple videos with fixed costs.

2. Agility in Production

AI-powered video creation is supposedly fast. You can generate content in a matter of hours, without having to schedule recordings or wait for post-production. This is ideal for companies that need frequent updates or bulk content.

3. Flexibility

AI avatars can be customized to meet a company’s specific needs. They can speak different languages, wear different outfits, and take on different personalities.

Disadvantages of AI Avatars

1. Verisimilitude and the Uncanny Valley

Despite advances, technology has yet to reach a level of total realism. Many avatars have lip-sync issues and unnatural gestures, falling into the so-called “uncanny valley” – a phenomenon in which robots or near-realistic human representations cause discomfort.

2. Lack of Non-Verbal Communication

AI avatars still struggle to replicate nonverbal communication effectively. Facial expressions, gestures, and nuances that convey emotions and intentions are often generic and can feel artificial. This reduces emotional connection and information retention by the audience.

3. Generic Avatars and Commoditization

Many companies use the same generic avatars provided by platforms, which can lead to a lack of identity and differentiation. When multiple videos feature the same characters, the message can become commoditized and lose impact.

4. Retention of Information

The human brain is excellent at detecting patterns and inconsistencies. When viewers realize they are watching an AI avatar, information retention may decrease, as authenticity and credibility are key factors in engagement.

Price comparison: is it worth it?

Synthesia

Synthesia offers different subscription plans:

  • Creator Plan: $804 per year, allowing you to create up to 360 minutes of video per year, which would be enough for a 6-hour video project.

HeyGen

HeyGen offers the following subscription plans:

  • Team Plan: $1440 per year, allowing the creation of up to 360 minutes of video per year, also enough for a 6-hour video project.

Human production at Silvertake

For a 6-hour studio recording project at Silvertake, costs can vary depending on the scope and complexity of the video:

  • Production Costs: Between R$15,000 and R$30,000 for a 6-hour recording project over two days, including pre-production fees, equipment, studio, editing and post-production.

Comparison

  • Synthesia: Approximately R$4,000
  • HeyGen: Approximately R$7,200
  • Human production: Approximately R$15,000 to R$30,000

While videos with AI avatars may seem more cost-effective at first glance, especially for smaller projects, costs can quickly escalate for larger projects.

Traditional studio production offers greater authenticity and quality, which can be crucial for certain types of content, such as in-depth training and high-impact marketing videos.

Silvertake's Experience with AI Avatars

At Silvertake Video, we specialize in creating impactful visual content that effectively communicates our clients’ messages. With years of experience in the video production industry, we have closely observed the development of AI technologies and their impact on the industry.

We have been leveraging AI technologies in our projects to deliver innovative and cost-effective solutions. We are currently experimenting with the use of AI avatars for multi-language translation, set and costume approval, and more.

These experiments help us better understand the limitations and possibilities of this technology, allowing us to offer accurate and personalized advice to our clients.

The Future of AI Avatars

Despite their current limitations, these technologies are expected to continue to evolve. In the future, we can expect AI avatars with improved verisimilitude, better facial expressions, and more natural gestures.

The evolution can be compared to that of AI-generated images, such as those produced by MidJourney and DALL-E, which are increasingly realistic but are still distinguishable with a close look.

Conclusion

AI avatar videos offer clear advantages in terms of cost and agility, but still face significant challenges in verisimilitude and nonverbal communication.

For content that requires high authenticity and emotional engagement, recording with real people is still the best option. However, for quick, low-cost, and low-display productions, AI avatars can be a viable and promising solution.

At Silvertake Video, we believe in the ideal combination of innovation and quality. If you are interested in exploring the possibilities of AI avatars or need authentic and engaging videos, visit our portfolio and find out how we can get your project off the ground.

related posts

request a quote

let's talk about your next video project?